The People’s Republic of China (PRC) law does not codify fraud as a standalone tort, but fraudulent conduct gives rise to general civil liability. Plaintiffs typically rely on the following causes of action:

  • Tortious liability for infliction of loss through fault. A party who, through fault (including intentional misconduct), infringes upon another party’s civil-law rights and interests and causes damage shall bear tort liability. Fraud-induced economic loss may be claimed under this general fault-based tort framework.
  • Rescission of the contract or legal act and restitution. Where a party is induced to enter into a juridical act by the other party’s fraudulent conduct, the deceived party may seek rescission of the contract. The legal framework addresses both frauds perpetrated by a counterparty and third-party fraud (where the counterparty knew or should have known of it). Where rescission is granted, the defrauding party shall compensate the innocent party for losses suffered, including reliance losses.
  • Unjust enrichment. Where the defrauding party has been enriched at the claimant’s expense without a lawful basis — for instance, following the rescission of a contract — the claimant may seek restitution of the benefit obtained.
  • Breach of the duty of good faith and pre-contractual disclosure. PRC law establishes the general principle that all civil subjects must act in accordance with good faith. Liability for culpa in contrahendo is imposed where a party, in the course of contract formation, negotiates in bad faith under the pretense of entering into a contract with no genuine intention to do so; deliberately conceals material facts relevant to the formation of the contract or provides false information; or engages in other conduct in breach of good faith — thereby causing loss to the other party.

China has specific statutory regimes addressing fraud across various sectors:

  • Criminal law. Proscribes core financial crimes, including contract fraud, fundraising fraud, and money laundering.
  • Anti-telecom fraud law. Criminalizes remote telecommunications fraud and establishes cross-border enforcement mechanisms.
  • Securities law and company law. Establish liability for misrepresentation, insider trading in capital markets, and dishonest conduct prejudicing company, shareholders or creditor interests.
  • Anti-unfair competition law. Regulates commercial fraud, including false advertising.
  • Banking regulatory law and insurance law. Establish specific regulatory frameworks for regulating financial fraud.

In foreign-related civil disputes where the defendant has no domicile in China, Chinese courts may exercise jurisdiction if any of the connecting factors fall within China: the place of contract conclusion or performance, the location of the subject matter or attachable property, the place of the tortious act, or the domicile of the defendant’s representative office, or any other factors the court may deem appropriate in order to assert jurisdiction.

Relevant connecting factors primarily include:

  • the defendant’s domicile, habitual residence, or branch location;
  • the place of the tortious act (including the place of the conduct and the place where the consequences occur);
  • the location of attachable assets; and
  • the place of contract conclusion or performance, or a valid jurisdiction agreement.

  • Tort claims. The law of the place of the tortious act generally applies. If parties share a common habitual residence, the law of that habitual residence applies. Parties may also mutually agree on the applicable law after the tort occurs.
  • Proprietary rights and asset tracing. For disputes over the ownership of movable or immovable property, the law of the place where the asset is located shall apply.

In principle, Chinese courts can take preservation and enforcement measures against all property with economic value, including:

  • cash and bank deposits;
  • immovables (land use rights, real estate) and movables (vehicles, equipment, etc.);
  • securities, fund shares, equity and intellectual property;
  • special assets, for example, the cash value of life insurance products, corporate annuities, pre-sale fund supervision accounts of real estate developers, and unmatured claims held by the debtor against third parties.

PRC law does not recognize common-law doctrines like equitable tracing, constructive trusts, or the lowest intermediate balance rule. Courts approach mixed-fund disputes through general evidentiary rules on the burden of proof. Parties must produce complete, continuous bank statements and forensic audit materials. In civil-criminal crossover cases, civil courts rely heavily on criminal financial audit reports to identify commingled funds.

PRC law does not provide for “equitable interest” or “constructive trust” under the common law system. Claimants cannot easily assert proprietary rights over converted assets in the common law manner. Instead, Chinese law relies on tortious liability or unjust enrichment (in personam claims). In insolvency, the defrauded party typically ranks as an unsecured creditor and shares in the debtor’s estate on a pari passu basis, rather than recovering specific assets ahead of others.

Proprietary claims for the return of original objects are subject to limitations:

  • Highly liquid assets. For currency, the “possession equals ownership” rule applies, converting proprietary claims into damages.
  • Bona fide purchaser. If a third party acquires the property in good faith, for reasonable consideration, and completes registration/delivery, the plaintiff loses the proprietary claim. However, in criminal fraud cases, the applicability of bona fide acquisition is significantly restricted. Courts and judicial authorities generally retain the statutory power to recover stolen property even from third parties, unless the third party meets heightened evidentiary requirements to prove they had absolutely no knowledge of the illicit origins of the assets.

PRC courts do not utilize the proprietary “tracing” concept. The plaintiff seeks to execute against the substituted asset as part of the defendant’s general estate. Remedies are achieved through:

  • Enforcement against assets. Seizing and enforcing against property registered to the defendant, including assets bought with misappropriated funds. For transfers to third parties, the plaintiff may seek to unwind the transfer through the creditor’s right of avoidance or by challenging the third party’s claim through enforcement objection proceedings.
  • Criminal restitution. Judicial authorities can confiscate substituted assets and illegal gains to order restitution to victims.
  • Pre-litigation preservation. Early freezing of identifiable substituted assets may be available to prevent dissipation.

PRC law does not provide for standalone freezing injunctions (e.g., Mareva injunctions) or without-notice search orders. Protective remedies are achieved through the “preservation” regime:

  • Property preservation. Freezing bank accounts and equity, or seizing movable and immovable assets to prevent asset dissipation.
  • Conduct preservation (injunction). Ordering the defendant to perform or refrain from specific acts (e.g., prohibiting asset disposal).
  • Evidence preservation. Securing evidence that may be destroyed or difficult to obtain later.
  • Security requirements. Courts typically require the applicant to provide security (cash or litigation preservation liability insurance) for both pre-litigation and litigation preservation.

PRC law lacks a common law “discovery” regime. Claimants bear the primary burden of proof, but can utilize the following tools:

  • Court orders and investigation. Petitioning the court for document production orders or obtaining court-issued investigation orders for lawyers to retrieve bank and government records.
  • Asset reporting and audits. The court can compel the judgment debtor to report major property changes (such as large expenditures or gratuitous transfers) up to one year prior to its receipt of the enforcement notice. If concealment or capital withdrawal is suspected, the creditor may apply to the court to appoint an auditing firm to conduct a judicial audit on the judgment debtor. Verified related audit expenses shall ultimately be borne by the defrauding party, making this a powerful tool to pierce complex accounting veils.
  • Warrants and reward notices. Courts may issue “search warrants” for physical premises where assets might have been concealed. Furthermore, the creditor can apply to publish reward notices on the national enforcement reward platform or online media, mobilizing the public to report hidden assets in exchange for a percentage of the successfully recovered funds.
  • Online monitoring. During the enforcement stage, the court utilizes the national “Online Enforcement Monitoring and Control System” to directly search the debtor’s bank deposits, securities, and real estate.

Pre-action disclosure for “fishing expeditions” to discover unknown assets or defendants is not available. However, PRC law permits “pre-action evidence preservation” to secure known evidence that might be destroyed before a lawsuit or arbitration is filed.

Yes, based on international treaties or the principle of reciprocity, but assistance is limited:

  • Service and evidence. PRC courts can assist in serving documents and collecting evidence, provided it does not prejudice China’s sovereignty or public interest.
  • No interim preservation. PRC courts do not directly recognize or enforce interim freezing injunctions issued by foreign courts.
  • Alternative routes. To freeze assets, foreign plaintiffs must initiate substantive proceedings domestically or apply for domestic preservation in China while seeking recognition of a final foreign judgment.
  • Anti-fraud cooperation. Public security authorities may assist in cross-border telecom and online fraud investigations.

Cross-border cooperation outcomes vary significantly by both mechanism and jurisdiction:

  • Inter-court civil judicial assistance (time-consuming). Requests for judicial assistance must follow international treaties or diplomatic channels. The Ministry of Justice serves as the designated “Central Authority” under the Hague Convention. While legally structured, this process involves multiple levels of administrative approval and is highly time-consuming (typically taking several months to over a year), making it far from ideal for international fraud cases where urgent asset preservation is required.
  • Regulatory cooperation (efficient but limited to public power). Chinese financial regulators and public security authorities, such as the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) and the Ministry of Public Security, are authorized to establish cross-border cooperation mechanisms. For instance, the CSRC’s cooperation via the IOSCO MMoU (International Organization of Securities Commissions Multilateral Memorandum of Understanding) is relatively efficient. However, this primarily serves administrative or criminal enforcement objectives and does not directly replace or prioritize private civil asset recovery.
  • Lawyer-to-lawyer cooperation. Lawyers across different jurisdictions, without having to go through any administrative or approval procedures, can often achieve speediness and effectiveness for cooperation with optimal results.

Commonly relied upon treaties include:

  • The Hague Service Convention and the Hague Evidence Convention. These are core multilateral treaties for cross-border service of process and taking of evidence in civil/commercial matters (with reservations made by China).
  • Bilateral Judicial Assistance Treaties (signed with nearly 40 countries covering service, evidence, recognition/enforcement of judgments, asset seizure and freezing).
  • UN Convention against Corruption (UNCAC) and the UN Convention against Transnational Organized Crime (UNTOC).
  • The New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards.

Final foreign civil and commercial judgments can be enforced under strict conditions:

  • De jure reciprocity. Chinese courts have substantially relaxed the reciprocity standard. Recognition is now possible if a Chinese judgment could theoretically be recognized under the foreign law.
  • Statutory refusal grounds. Enforcement may be refused due to lack of jurisdiction, procedural defects (e.g., lack of proper service), fraud, parallel proceedings, or public policy violations.
  • Restrictions on punitive damages. Chinese courts have the power to refuse recognition of the portion of a foreign judgment awarding punitive damages that significantly exceed actual losses.

  • Civil freezing orders. Foreign interim orders are not recognized. Creditors must apply to recognize the final judgment on the merits and simultaneously seek domestic preservation measures under PRC civil procedure.
  • Criminal confiscation orders. Enforced via diplomatic or judicial channels based on bilateral treaties or conventions (e.g., UNCAC), subject to review under the PRC Criminal Procedure Law.

Insolvency law and fraud/asset recovery claims are deeply intertwined.

  • Stay of individual recovery. Upon acceptance of a bankruptcy application, preservation measures against the debtor’s property shall be released, and individual civil enforcement proceedings are stayed.
  • Centralized jurisdiction. Pending fraud claims are suspended until the administrator takes over. All new lawsuits must be filed exclusively with the bankruptcy court.
  • Strategy to bypass. Suing a guarantor (rather than the bankrupt principal debtor) falls outside centralized bankruptcy jurisdiction, allowing creditors to expedite proceedings in other courts.
  • Cross-border recognition. Foreign bankruptcy representatives may apply for recognition and enforcement in China based on treaties or reciprocity.
  • Enforcement-to-bankruptcy mechanism. Where asset recovery is stalled and a corporate debtor is insolvent, the enforcement court may transfer the case for bankruptcy review upon the written consent of either a creditor or the debtor. Upon acceptance, the original enforcement court(s) must transfer seized or frozen assets to the administrator within seven days. In practice, if an enforcement case progresses rapidly and assets have been auctioned with the ruling delivered to the buyer or funds transferred before bankruptcy acceptance, these assets shall no longer be deemed as belonging to the debtor, and the administrator cannot demand the transfer or redistribution thereof.

Insolvency administrators have statutory duties to recover dissipated assets through:

  • Exercising recovery rights. Clawing back property dissipated through fraud, gratuitous transfers or debt evasion.
  • Combating sham litigation. Revoking effective legal instruments fabricated through malicious collusion.
  • Pursuing management liability. If corporate directors, supervisors or senior executives breach their duties of loyalty and diligence (e.g., participating in or turning a blind eye to fraud) or use their positions to misappropriate corporate property, the administrator may recover the relevant property and hold them personally liable for civil compensation for causing the bankruptcy. This has become an increasingly potent weapon under the revised company law.
  • Pursuing capital contribution. Where shareholders have failed to make their subscribed capital contributions in full, or have unlawfully withdrawn their contributions post-injection, the administrator has the right to demand payment of the outstanding amounts directly into the bankruptcy estate. In fraud cases involving shell companies or controlling shareholders, this is often one of the most direct and effective recovery tools available to pierce the corporate veil.
  • Reviving time-barred claims. The limitation period for the debtor’s claims against third parties automatically restarts upon the court’s acceptance of the bankruptcy application. This enables the administrator to pursue recovery of debts that would otherwise be unenforceable due to the lapse of the limitation period.

Yes, the enterprise bankruptcy regime provides robust clawback tools:

  • One-year look-back. For gratuitous transfers, transactions at clearly unreasonable prices, or providing security for unsecured debts.
  • Six-month look-back. For preferential settlements made to individual creditors when the debtor was already insolvent.
  • Absolute invalidity. Acts to conceal assets or fabricate false debts are void ab initio, not subject to any look-back period limitation.
  • Creditors’ supplementary rights. If the administrator fails to act, individual creditors may file lawsuits invoking civil avoidance rights, with recovered property accruing to the entire

PRC practice traditionally follows the “criminal proceedings first” principle, which creates a strategic dilemma for fraud victims.

  • The double-edged sword of criminal reporting. Filing a criminal complaint is a powerful tool — it triggers state investigative powers entirely unavailable in civil proceedings, including compelled bank disclosure and immediate account freezing without the claimant posting security. It can also generate immense pressure on fraudsters to settle. However, this comes at a severe procedural cost: once criminal proceedings commence, civil courts will routinely dismiss or stay related civil claims involving the “same legal facts” pending the criminal resolution. This suspension can trap victims in a waiting game that lasts for years.
  • Strategic breakthroughs for parallel proceedings. To avoid the paralyzing effect of a civil stay, experienced practitioners utilize specific “breakthroughs” where the legal facts or subjects are distinguishable. Parallel proceedings are permitted when:
    • Suing the guarantor separately. Where the principal debtor is involved in a crime, the creditor may seek civil liability solely from a guarantor. Since the guarantor is not personally involved in the crime, the court will hear the case independently.
    • Pursuing corporate liability. If a company’s legal representative or employee commits criminal fraud, the victim can launch a parallel civil suit against the corporate entity itself, arguing apparent agency or management fault. The court must hear this separately due to the different legal subjects involved.
    • Administrator actions in insolvency. Civil recovery actions brought by an insolvency administrator (such as avoidance actions or capital contribution claims) are generally not stayed by related criminal proceedings, providing an independent recovery track.

China does not have the common law “civil forfeiture” regime. However, two non-conviction-based mechanisms exist:

  • Expedited restitution. Public security authorities can return frozen funds directly to victims of telecom/online fraud without waiting for a criminal conviction.
  • Confiscation of illegal gains. In major crimes (e.g., corruption, terrorism) where suspects have absconded or died, courts can rule on confiscation without a conviction.

Victims can participate via:

  • Direct restitution. Ordered in criminal judgments, taking priority over state fines.
  • Ancillary civil action. Allowed during criminal proceedings, though practically limited to material losses from physical harm or property destruction (not general fraud).
  • Non-conviction confiscation. Victims may claim rights during the six-month public notice period.
  • Supplementary civil actions. Filing separate civil suits for unrecovered shortfalls.

  • Statutory priority. Victim restitution takes precedence over state fines and confiscation. However, pre-existing secured creditors (e.g., mortgages) generally rank ahead of victim restitution.
  • Pro-rata distribution. For telecom fraud, commingled funds that cannot be traced to individual victims are distributed pro rata based on verified losses.

General limitation. Three years from the date of discovery (maximum 20 years).

Exclusion period. The right to seek rescission of a contract induced by fraud is subject to a strict one-year exclusion period (maximum five years), which cannot be suspended or extended.

Avoidance action. Creditor’s avoidance rights must be exercised within one year of discovery (maximum five years).

Fraud itself does not extend limitation periods. However:

  • Interruption. Demanding performance, filing lawsuits or reporting to authorities interrupts the period, causing it to run afresh.
  • Criminal proceedings. In cases with overlapping civil and criminal elements, the limitation period for a victim’s civil claims is interrupted (not merely suspended) during the period in which the public security bureau or procuratorate investigates the suspected economic crime. If the public security bureau decides to withdraw the case or the procuratorate decides not to prosecute, the limitation period restarts in full from the day following such decision. This is a materially more favorable outcome for victims than mere suspension, as it affords the victim a completely new limitation period rather than only the remainder of the original period.

Common defenses raised by defendants include:

  • Bona fide Third parties claiming good faith acquisition.
  • Enforcement objections based on substantive rights. Third parties asserting pre-existing leases or otherwise having entered into conveyance agreements and paid full consideration, with actual possession prior to the court’s seizure, may object to the enforcement despite the absence of a formal title transfer.
  • Time bars. Expiry of limitation or exclusion periods.
  • Corporate exemption. Companies arguing the fraud was an unauthorized, personal act of an employee. The legal framework for determining corporate liability turns on whether the employee’s conduct constitutes apparent authority or an act within the scope of employment, and essentially whether the company was at fault in the management and custody of its official company chops/seals.
  • Sham divorce. Transferring high-value assets to a debt-free spouse to evade enforcement. Fraudsters often suddenly divorce upon the discovery of fraud or impending litigation, allocating joint real estate entirely to the debt-free spouse. PRC courts scrutinize the chronology closely, comparing the date the debt arose against the date of the property division. Creditors may invoke the civil right of avoidance to challenge and unwind such grossly disproportionate arrangements.
  • Mistaken transfer. Third parties claiming frozen funds were transferred by mistake.
  • Jurisdictional Raising forum non conveniens to delay proceedings.

If a claim for fraud is successful, the plaintiff may receive remedies including compensatory damages for actual/foreseeable losses (requiring strict proof), rescission of contracts with restitution, revocation of fraudulent transfers, and unjust enrichment claims.

China operates a civil law system and has no doctrine of equity as under the common law system. Constructive trusts and equitable liens — remedies that a Hong Kong or English court would impose as a matter of course in fraud cases — have no direct equivalent under the PRC law.

The strategic implications are profound, as the divergence between the PRC law and the common law system carries significant practical consequences for asset recovery. The PRC law provides personal remedies (in personam) where the common law would provide proprietary ones. For insolvent or near-insolvent defendants — the typical profile in serious fraud cases — the absence of the constructive trust doctrine is a structural gap that materially reduces domestic recovery prospects.

This is precisely why, in complex cross-border asset recovery, it is often strategically imperative to bring a proprietary claim or seek a freezing injunction in a common law jurisdiction — such as Hong Kong, England, or the BVI — first, rather than relying solely on litigation in mainland China.

Sophisticated claimants must build the offshore component of their recovery strategy as early as possible to secure the proprietary base of the claim and then utilize PRC courts concurrently for enforcement and preservation against onshore assets.

The principal mechanisms for asset realization are court-supervised freezing, public online auctions, and direct transfers of liquid assets. However, the distribution of proceeds heavily depends on the nature of the debtor and the timing of the creditor’s actions.

  • The “first-to-attach” priority rule. For corporate judgment debtors outside of formal insolvency, pro rata distribution does not apply. Instead, unsecured creditors are satisfied in strict chronological order based on when each creditor’s seizure or freezing measure was officially registered against the asset. This is essentially a “first-to-attach” priority rule.
  • The practical consequence (“the race to the courthouse”). In fraud cases involving a corporate defendant, the identity of the first creditor to obtain a preservation order over a specific asset is absolutely decisive. A creditor who freezes an asset just one day earlier than a competing creditor takes their share in full before the later creditor receives a single cent. This makes early application for property preservation not merely tactically desirable, but potentially the difference between full recovery and nothing at all. It guarantees a high-stakes “race to the courthouse” among competing creditors.
  • Interaction with secured assets. The existence of a third-party mortgage over the fraudster’s property does not bar a judgment creditor from applying to seize and auction that asset. A mortgage is a value right, not a right to block enforcement. Upon judicial auction, the proceeds are applied first to discharge the secured mortgage debt in full, with any surplus then applied to satisfy the judgment creditor’s claim. Additionally, in criminal enforcement proceedings, victim restitution takes absolute priority over ordinary civil debts, fines, and state confiscation.

Interest and costs are recoverable under certain conditions and subject to limitations.

  • Interest. Claimants can recover principal, default interest, and higher interest for failure to pay post-judgment.
  • Costs. Court fees and preservation fees are recoverable from the losing party as a matter of course. Legal fees — counsel fees, expert fees, and investigation costs — are generally not recoverable, subject to certain exceptions, such as:
    • Where the underlying contract expressly provides that legal fees are recoverable from the defaulting party, courts will generally give effect to that clause, subject to a reasonableness review.
    • Specific statutory regimes expressly provide for legal fee recovery — most notably, intellectual property litigation and securities misrepresentation claims.
    • In limited circumstances involving abuse of process, bad faith, or other egregious misconduct, courts may award legal fees pursuant to applicable judicial interpretations issued by the Supreme People’s Court.
  • Position in fraud cases. In commercial fraud litigation, where the claimant can demonstrate that legal fees incurred in pursuing recovery constitute a reasonably foreseeable and quantifiable loss caused by the fraud, some courts will include a legal fee component within the damages award. However, the amounts awarded are typically conservative, and judicial practice varies significantly across jurisdictions.

The jurisdiction poses structural challenges (no discovery mechanism, high evidentiary bar for fraud, largely irrecoverable legal costs). However, it is increasingly workable for well-resourced claimants using coordinated cross-border strategies, aided by robust national enforcement monitoring systems and criminal investigative powers.

A PRC court shall grant or deny an application for preservation of property within five days from the date of receipt; in cases of emergency, the court shall rule within 48 hours. Practically, the applicant shall provide security (cash or guarantee) and must commence legal action (i.e., litigation or arbitration) within 30 days following the court action.

  • Third-party Litigation Funding (TPLF). TPLF remains unregulated and legally precarious. There are prominent cases that have directly addressed the issue and found domestic funding agreements invalid “as contrary to public interest”, with the funder denied its contractual return. There is no regulatory framework or Supreme People’s Court guidance recognizing or legitimizing the practice, making it a high-risk funding route in mainland China. Where cross-border asset recovery or third-party litigation funding is governed by a foreign law, the resulting arrangements are less susceptible to challenge on validity or public policy grounds before PRC courts, absent a manifest violation of PRC mandatory rules or fundamental public policy.
  • Contingency fees. Contingency fee arrangements are permitted for certain categories of claims. In practice, Chinese law firms undertaking complex fraud recovery matters on a contingency basis typically receive a certain cut of the actual recovery, with the specific percentage reflecting the risk profile of the engagement, but a 2021 opinion issued by the Ministry of Justice, in conjunction with other agencies, imposed progressive percentage caps on contingency fees. The arrangement is most commonly structured as a hybrid “base retainer plus success fee” rather than pure contingency. This is currently the most widely used funding mechanism for claimants.

Practitioners must navigate several critical pitfalls, which require close coordination between PRC and foreign counsel from the outset:

  • Civil-criminal sequencing. As noted in Question 9.1, above, recklessly triggering a criminal investigation without securing assets first can inadvertently freeze the victim’s own civil recovery efforts for years. Sequencing is everything.
  • Service of process — the time bomb. Service of process on foreign defendants via the Hague Convention or diplomatic channels routinely takes 6 to 18 months. This severely delays the entire proceedings and creates a massive window during which the defendant can dissipate assets. Even for domestic defendants who evade service, courts must resort to “service by public notice,” which adds a further 60-day statutory waiting period. Foreign practitioners frequently underestimate how these service timelines compress the practical window for asset preservation.
  • Evidence — the authentication burden. China operates under strict formalistic evidentiary rules. Foreign-origin documentary evidence must be notarized in the country of origin and then authenticated (apostilled or consularized). Furthermore, electronic evidence frequently requires judicial identification through a PRC notary or court-appointed expert. Courts retain broad discretion to exclude evidence that does not meet these strict formal requirements, even if its authenticity is not genuinely in dispute. This front-loads significant cost and time into the pre-litigation phase.
  • Evidentiary bar for fraud. Proving fraud in a civil court requires a high “beyond reasonable doubt” standard, functioning almost like a criminal evidentiary threshold in a civil setting. This places a heavy burden on claimants who must prove fraudulent intent frequently through circumstantial evidence alone.
  • Time constraints. Claimants must be hyper-vigilant regarding time bars. Deceptively short limitation periods apply — specifically the one-year exclusion period for contract rescission and the strict two-year period to apply for compulsory enforcement after a judgment takes effect.

The 2022 Anti-Telecom and Online Fraud Law established a vital “green channel” for expedited non-litigation restitution, allowing police to return frozen fraud-related funds to victims prior to a criminal judgment.

The trend is mixed but net-positive for claimants, with expansion in some areas and friction in others. The expanding side includes:

  • Foreign judgment recognition is broader — the 2023 Civil Procedure Law Amendment codified de jure reciprocity, and the January 2024 HK-Mainland Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments regime now covers non-monetary judgments for the first time.
  • The April 2024 Mutual Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters Implementing Provisions provide the first operational rules for cross-border criminal asset recovery.
  • At the enforcement stage, courts must now proactively deploy the electronic asset inquiry system; judgment debtors who dissipate assets face imprisonment.
  • Cryptocurrency is gradually being treated as recoverable property (Supreme People’s Court 2023 draft Minutes; 2024 AML interpretation).
  • Personal liability for directors and officers expanded under the revised Company Law (July 2024).

In some other areas, developments may restrict claimants’ abilities to recover assets:

  • Judgment database access has shrunk — case names anonymized since 2022 and publication volumes are declining.
  • The introduction of the “work secret” concept under Article 64 of the revised State Secrets Law (effective May 2024) creates an additional, loosely defined category of protected information that may be invoked by Chinese authorities to resist disclosure in fraud recovery proceedings.
  • The continued absence of a “Norwich Pharmacal” pre-trial discovery equivalent. While courts do have the power to investigate and require banks and registration authorities to provide information, in practice, courts generally require applicants to provide specific asset leads. This produces a fundamental paradox: you can only search for what you already know exists.
  • Furthermore, TPLF remains legally precarious. Some were supported by local courts, while some local courts ruled that permitting a third party with no direct interest in the proceedings to profit from funding litigation undermines the normative foundations of civil justice, encourages “speculative exploitation of the court process”, and “is harmful to the proper order of judicial administration”. The regulatory vacuum has produced sharply inconsistent judicial outcomes.

The most significant trend is the shift from de facto to de jure reciprocity, substantially easing the recognition and enforcement of foreign commercial judgments in China.

This means that where, as a matter of foreign law, a Chinese judgment would in principle be recognized in that jurisdiction, Chinese courts may treat the reciprocity requirement as satisfied — without requiring proof of any prior instance of actual recognition.

This development significantly improves the prospects for victims of transnational fraud seeking to bring foreign judgments into China for enforcement against assets located within the jurisdiction.