Mariana Dam client representation battle set for 2027 appeal

Court of Appeal says client committee can appeal October ruling preventing it from changing law firms
Prefer the Global Legal Post on Google
Mariana Dam client representation battle set for 2027 appeal

jimmonkphotography / Shutterstock.com

Members of a client committee representing claimants in the Mariana Dam litigation have been granted leave to appeal an October ruling that prevented them from replacing legacy Pogust Goodhead as solicitors of record in the long-running claim against BHP.

The decision followed a half-day hearing in November, during which 13 of the committee’s 16 members appealed Mr Justice Waksman’s October judgment.

Waksman ruled that the client committee lacked the power to terminate the retainer with PGMBM – formerly known as Pogust Goodhead – in favour of new solicitors Bailey Glasser International (BGI), over control of the ongoing Mariana Dam litigation. Lord Justice Fraser and Lord Justice Meade granted permission for the appeal.

According to skeleton arguments seen by this title, the client committee – who instructed Humphries Kerstetter – challenged Waksman’s findings that the committee lacked the requisite authority to change solicitors. The committee argued it had the authority to end the conditional fee agreements and litigation management agreements underlying the litigation, despite the judge construing the agreements otherwise. And the committee argued the clients could instruct BGI, despite Waksman finding they lacked the authority to do so.

PGMBM denies the grounds for appeal and seeks to uphold the earlier ruling. 

Faranak Ghajavand, head of commercial disputes at BGI, said: “A higher court will now consider whether claimants can choose who represents them by acting through the committee. The committee was set up under PGMBM’s own contracts specifically to manage the litigation and take important decisions on the claimants’ behalf.”

He added: “Our focus is on the committee having its arguments fully heard, so that the case against BHP can move forward with strength to secure full and fair compensation for all claimants.”

Marcelo Krenak, chairman of the client committee, called the granting of leave to appeal “an important step for the claimants”.

He added: “The committee was created to be the collective voice of the victims of Mariana, and we will continue to defend their right to choose who represents them. Our focus remains the fair compensation they have been awaiting for more than 10 years.”

A PGMBM spokeswoman said: “PGMBM remains confident in the legal basis of the High Court’s judgment, which confirmed the firm’s continued representation of hundreds of thousands of people affected by the Mariana dam disaster in the proceedings against BHP, and will continue to defend that judgment vigorously.”

She added: “Any further delay would only prolong proceedings that have already lasted for years, causing further harm to victims who have been waiting for more than a decade to receive fair compensation.

“Whatever the intentions behind these challenges, the resulting uncertainty risks benefiting the defendants rather than the people who have already waited 11 years for justice.”

She concluded that the firm’s focus was “on moving the case forward in preparation for the April 2027 quantum trial, and has the funding, insurance and resourcing in place to progress clients’ claims and secure the compensation that they have waited more than a decade for”.

The main litigation will proceed under its existing timetable towards the Stage Two trial, scheduled for April 2027, with permission to appeal the earlier liability judgment having previously been refused by the Court of Appeal.

In June, PGMBM announced new funding of £150m for the claim from Gramercy Funds Management, alongside a strategic partnership with Quinn Emanuel (QE) as co-counsel; QE’s senior partner later joined that team, while BGI teamed up with Hausfeld.

London-based BGI operates under an agreement with US firm Bailey & Glasser. BGI describes its partners Jeremy Evans and Faranak Ghajavand and senior associate Callum Walters as former key members of the PGMBM team working on the BHP group litigation; they were subsequently reunited with Thomas Goodhead, co-founder and former CEO of PGMBM, at BGI.

BGI was also boosted by the arrival of seven lawyers, led by partner Simon Gilbert-Kent, to expand its class actions and commercial disputes practice. Five of those joining came from PGMBM, one from Thaxted Capital and one from Minteo.

Jeremy Evans, managing partner of BGI, said: “This is a team built for the cases ahead. BGI is not only a group action firm. We already act on high-value commercial matters, and we now have the depth to grow that work and bring collective redress claims on an international scale. London is one of the world’s leading centres for international group litigation, and BGI intends to be at the forefront.”

The appointments follow Guy Robson’s arrival at BGI last month as a partner to head up the Latin American practice.

The case continues. 

Email your news and story ideas to: [email protected]

The Global Legal Post

© 2026 The Global Legal Post. All Rights Reserved

Top